The Lip Bar Is Expanding Its Audience, Not Abandoning Black Women

Black women have long been the backbone of the beauty industry, influencing trends, building brands and spending their dollars on products that don’t always return the favor. So when a Black-owned beauty brand makes it clear that its next chapter includes reaching customers beyond its core audience, why does that suddenly become a problem? That’s the conversation surrounding The Lip Bar, the Detroit-born beauty company founded by Melissa Butler, a past EBONY Power 100 Business Disruptor honoree, following comments made by its Vice President of Marketing, Yasmine Harema, during an Adweek discussion.

During the conversation, Harema explained that The Lip Bar has historically catered to millennial Black women, a demographic that knows the brand and its products well. However, with Target serving as its largest retail partner, the company faces a complicated reality as the retailer continues navigating criticism surrounding its diversity, equity and inclusion decisions. For The Lip Bar, expanding its audience isn’t about replacing the women who helped build the business. It’s about ensuring that other shoppers recognize the brand has something for them, too.

Harema explained that while Black millennial women will continue to be celebrated, the company must create opportunities for white millennial women and other potential customers to see themselves in its marketing. She also discussed how product preferences differ among consumers, with some shoppers gravitating toward everyday makeup rather than the bold colors and signature Fast Face offerings associated with The Lip Bar. It’s a fairly standard conversation about customer acquisition, product development and brand positioning. Yet online, the remarks sparked criticism from consumers questioning whether the company was distancing itself from Black women.

But since when did expanding a customer base become synonymous with abandoning one? Black consumers regularly purchase products from brands founded by people of other backgrounds without questioning whether those companies are betraying their original audiences. The expectation that Black-owned businesses should remain exclusively within Black communities creates an unfair limitation on their ability to compete. Supporting Black entrepreneurship should also mean supporting the possibility of Black-owned companies becoming household names across demographics.

The irony is that we frequently question why the beauty and fashion industries have so few longstanding, heritage Black-owned brands with the global recognition, generational influence and financial staying power of their competitors. We want Black-owned beauty houses and fashion labels that can exist for decades, become household names and eventually be passed down to the next generation. Yet when those same businesses make the decisions necessary to grow, attract new customers and compete on a larger scale, some of us are quick to question their loyalty. We cannot demand more Black-owned legacy brands while simultaneously placing restrictions on how they build those legacies. That’s not fair to the founders who have spent years creating businesses that deserve to exist beyond a single demographic or generation.

Butler addressed the backlash directly on Threads, explaining that although The Lip Bar has been publicly critical of Target, leaving the retailer isn’t financially realistic. The company has instead increased marketing investments in its website and Amazon while maintaining a presence at Walmart and pursuing opportunities with Ulta. These decisions reflect the financial realities of operating a growing beauty business, where retail distribution, visibility and revenue can determine whether a company survives.

The founder also reminded consumers of the company’s longstanding investment in Black communities, including HBCU collections, community programming and $40,000 in support for Black-owned businesses. Those initiatives shouldn’t disappear from the conversation simply because the company wants to introduce its products to additional shoppers. A brand’s commitment to its community should be measured by its actions over time, not reduced to a few moments from a marketing discussion.

To be fair, Harema’s remarks weren’t perfectly articulated. Even Butler acknowledged that her marketing executive could have chosen her words more carefully. The suggestion that newer customers prefer more wearable products could unintentionally reinforce assumptions about what Black women wear compared with white women. Black beauty has never existed within one aesthetic, and consumers have every right to question messaging that appears to narrow their identities.

Still, imperfect wording shouldn’t automatically invalidate a company’s larger mission. The Lip Bar was founded to challenge an industry that historically overlooked Black women, and its ability to compete beyond that original audience can be viewed as an extension of that mission rather than a rejection of it. The goal should be creating more room at the beauty counter without asking the women who helped build the brand to surrender their place.

Perhaps Butler posed the most important question throughout this discourse: “Why do our brands have a ceiling?” Black-owned businesses deserve the opportunity to grow, diversify their audiences and pursue financial stability without having their cultural loyalty questioned at every turn. If we genuinely want to see Black-owned beauty and fashion companies become the heritage brands of tomorrow, we have to allow them the room to become exactly that. The Lip Bar can continue celebrating Black women while welcoming everyone else to the beauty conversation. Building something for Black women and building something that the world wants aren’t opposing ambitions. They’re how a legacy begins.

Updated: October 29, 2026 — 9:02 am