
I didn’t know what to expect when I arrived at Wanted, a new original musical that opened on Broadway on November 8. I knew it was inspired by real-life twin sisters Mary and Martha Clarke and family history, so it only seemed right to bring my mother, who loves musicals that tell stories about us.
She called it provocative. I left thinking about the sisters’ fight for what was rightfully theirs: their family’s land, security and future. Their robberies drive the plot, but what resonated with me was the refusal to let someone else decide what your family deserves. And the music made that fight feel uplifting, rhythmic and toe-tapping, rather than weighed down by trauma.

Wanted follows two sisters determined to save the land they and their mother have toiled on for generations. And nothing is going to stand in their way — especially the color of their skin.
Based on the inspiring tales of her great-great-aunts, Angelica Chéri, who is the first Black woman in nearly 50 years to write both the book and lyrics of a wholly original Broadway musical, has beautifully woven a story about Mary and Martha Clarke, born on the land where their family was once enslaved, who are finally ready to buy it from their white landlord and former family owner.
He chastises them, saying they should never forget their place in this world because of race, even if they could pass for white somewhere else, and raises the price. At this point, the sisters are determined to get their “inheritance” and pass for white as they travel to other towns to raise more funds. They quickly discover, with the aid of the revolver “Ole Betsy” their mother gave them for protection on their journey, that taking the money is faster and more lucrative than working for it. The famed outlaw Clarke Sisters are born.
This tale could have been mired in Black trauma, but instead Chéri and her writing partner, composer Ross Baum, chose to make this a story steeped in gospel, laughter and the gumption to get what is rightfully theirs.

Wanted features the Kinfolk, a chorus of ancestors angelically dressed in white, who act as the story’s moral compass, telling us of the young women’s plight, their fight to right wrongs, and the ultimate culmination of their journey. The chorus includes Aaron Arnell Harrington, Jennie Harney-Fleming, Rayshun LaMarr, Hailey Thomas, Harris Matthew and Melody A. Betts, who deliver a tour-de-force moment of theater that blew the whole audience away.

Solea Pfeiffer and Liisi LaFontaine play Mary and Martha Clarke, respectively, and their characters both navigate this experience in very different ways. One wants the life she’s witnessed but never experienced from the other side, while the other could never fully embrace the life she’s witnessing while passing. Both women are stars in the making.
Ledisi, who just received a 2027 Grammy nomination for Best Jazz Vocal Album: For Dinah, stars as their mother, Tallulah Clarke, giving us a taste of why she’s earned that 17th nomination. The Chi alum Luke James plays Elijah, bringing soulful vocals and quiet intensity.

And then there are Sissy and Flo — Aurelia Williams and Awa Sal Secka — two housekeepers who work in the house of fellow outlaw Jesse (Bradley Jaden). Unlike others, they can tell there is something different about the two young women who come to stay at his home, playfully delivered in the song “Dangerous.” Together, they play out like a perfect comedic pair, bringing levity to this intense story.

Wanted is a show that the Black community can relate to: the desire to be rewarded with what should already be rightfully ours. But the show’s music and heart bring forth a sentiment that can entertain all audiences.
Wanted is playing at the James Earl Jones Theatre in New York City.