Op-ed: Black Boys Shouldn’t Have to Shrink to Survive

Some parents of Black boys hope to wait until middle school to have “the talk,” or the conversation between caregivers and Black boys on how to navigate interactions with the people in order to survive. After this weekend, I wonder whether parents need to initiate the conversation as early as preschool.

On Saturday, October 24, a youth soccer dispute involving the athletic performance of three-year-old Nevada Pierre brought police to a field in Winter Park, Florida. Nevada was already playing with the five-year-olds. Winter Park police say a league official called officers following a disagreement with Nevada’s parents. Nevada’s mother, Martasia Griffin, alleges that other parents complained about her son’s dominance on the field and not passing the ball. 

Perhaps Nevada could have passed the ball more. But what three-year-old shares everything? Toddlers between three and five are all learning to share, cooperate, and regulate their emotions. If every toddler who hogged a toy or refused to take turns prompted a police response, officers would spend their days visiting local daycares and Pre-K classrooms.

Instead of celebrating a toddler’s talent or resolving a disagreement, adults escalated a children’s soccer game into a police matter. Ironically, sports boast about teaching conflict resolution, communication, and leadership, but it appears those skills are reserved for children, not their parents. 

Although police rarely intervene in toddler soccer games, Black boys frequently encounter disproportionate punishment before they enter kindergarten.

According to the 2021-2022 Department of Education’s Civil Rights Data, Black boys represented just 9% of public preschool enrollment but accounted for 30% of preschool children who received out-of-school suspensions and 25% of those expelled. A Yale study helps explain this disparity. Researchers asked early childhood educators to watch videos of preschoolers and identify challenging behavior. None of the children misbehaved. Yet educators spent more time watching Black children, particularly Black boys, as they anticipated trouble.

Maybe “the talk” is warranted at three-years-old because there are adults searching for reasons to punish Black children before it’s developmentally appropriate. 

Nevada’s reported behavior hardly qualifies as threatening or troubling. He’s a soccer enthusiast and a possible prodigy who excels against older children. Yet the dispute surrounding his performance raises another question: Why must Black people diminish their excellence to protect other people’s comfort?

America has a long history of punishing Black people who challenge racial expectations through our confidence, independence, or achievement.

In the Jim Crow South, white Americans branded Black people “uppity Negros” when we refused to accept our assigned place in society. Correcting our counterparts, demanding equal treatment, walking with confidence, or succeeding beyond white expectations could provoke retaliation.

The terror had a singular aim: to remind Black people we were powerless. To survive, Black Americans learned to demonstrate competence while remaining humble and to achieve success without too much celebration. 

This year marked the 105th anniversary of the Tulsa Race Massacre. In 1921, a white mob destroyed Greenwood, a prosperous Black community in Oklahoma with over 100 Black-owned businesses. It was speculated that the violence occurred after an accusation against a young Black man ignited racial violence. However, we’ve since learned the attack was intentional and coordinated. The root of the issue was simple: a reminder that “uppity Negros” could and would be punished. 

Of course, a toddler’s soccer dispute does not compare to the destruction of an entire community. However, both invite us to examine America’s history of weaponizing Black confidence and achievements.

https://www.threads.com/@msrachelforlittles/post/De9bSNjHN7q?xmt=AQG0bHx8Oo1aCAJ2yr1QfYnyfS5jTPdhWNNZ2A3RSWUzDQ
https://www.threads.com/@msrachelforlittles/post/De9bSNjHN7q?xmt=AQG0bHx8Oo1aCAJ2yr1QfYnyfS5jTPdhWNNZ2A3RSWUzDQ

In Nevada’s traumatic situation, I recognize a familiar pattern in the broader treatment of Black children. During my time as a middle school teacher, I repeatedly advocated for Black girls and boys whose confidence was seen as arrogance, whose curiosity was labeled defiance, and whose enthusiasm was classified as disruption. 

https://www.threads.com/@msrachelforlittles/post/De9bSNjHN7q?xmt=AQG0bHx8Oo1aCAJ2yr1QfYnyfS5jTPdhWNNZ2A3RSWUzDQ

Nevada’s mother says her son left the field wondering whether he had scored too many goals because these experiences teach Black children to question their instincts, conceal their gifts, and prioritize other people’s comfort over their own development. They also teach Nevada’s teammates and other kids how to treat their Black counterparts. 

As this story gained traction, i9 Sports, the youth soccer league, opened an internal investigation. Many notable figures like Ms. Rachel, weighed in on what happened to Nevada. Eddie Johnson, former U.S. Men’s National Team player invited Nevada to join his January 2027 camp. 

This public support cannot miss the clear message: being Black and excellent labels you a target. For generations, Black parents have taught their sons how to speak, respond, and behave. Now, it’s clear we must begin this humiliating ritual even earlier.

Updated: October 27, 2026 — 3:02 pm